Well, some first impressions on the PS5. As background, I had a PS4, never got a pro. I do have a One X, a 4k TV (non OLED ambilight) and a PC so powerful it's on a CIA watchlist.
Unboxing and general impressions first. Well, it's huge. It is both larger than I thought and also not so large that I think it's utterly ridiculous (it's close though). I'm using it on its side and the black plastic mini stand IS ridiculous - the entire thing smacks a little bit of design for design's sake and the One X next to it looks infinitely classier. But I do also quite like it, for simply being different. The set up was painless - I had to fiddle a lot to get a decent picture, but once done I was pretty satisfied. I don't think my TV is really good enough though by today's standards, so an OLED might need to be on the cards (my partner rarely comments on any of my tech purchases but she was astonished when I was moaning about the picture on my TV :D )
Anyhoo, the menu is, at least partially, a weird UI step back. The XMB was always wonderful. Making it look and feel a bit more like the Xbox UI seems crazy, though I appreciate things have moved on and it's getting more and more complex to categorise all the things a console needs to do. I could see a few improvements to the UI coming over the lifespan of the console though - it feels very fragmented and messy in bits. The Xbox UI has improved a lot, but still feels a bit weird too to be fair. It's not a disaster though and easy to use (and not a million miles from what's come before). I also can't see how to do it better, but then I'm not a UI designer.
So, the controller. I was surprised when all the additional features in it were announced and MS's response was pretty much "meh". I can only imagine they tried using it. While the form factor is better (than the Dualshock) and I guess the adaptive triggers are OK, the general rumble is just…. annoying? Astrobot almost made me feel a bit nauseous with all the mad buzzing and shit. It adds nothing for me, but then I've never been a huge fan of rumble in general, so I appreciate it could well be a me problem. Taps when you walk along, and "wind" or "water" being simulated in your hands is just… stupid? Distracting? Overall the pad is considerably better than the PS4 one, that's undeniable. The touchpad and mike are cool, if gimmicky. I'd still prefer async'ed sticks but the bigger form factor is a lot better. And to be honest, while I might've taken the Xbox Elite pad's (which I occasionally use on PC) choice of manually set trigger stops rather than the automatic route, I'll reserve judgement.
Ratchet and Clank, is wonderful, looks great and plays well. No surprises there. It is occasionally a little launch title esque in how it throws effects at the screen to show off, but a lot of the lighting and environmental design is breath-taking. Again, I'm not entirely sold on the pad integration - the adaptive triggers are…. fine? I'll play it more and see.
The big surprise was God of War. Holy, fucking, shit! :O I'd only really clocked it in passing - I knew it made original PS4s and Pros run at full tilt with fans at 100% and looked good, but I hadn't really looked into it much. I loved the original original, and then fell away from the series after the violence porn and dodgy bit in one of them (was it 2 or 3? with a woman tied to a cog?) made me re-evaluate how I'd like to spend my time, but this seems a very different beast. The graphics though. Dear god. It feels a bit walking simulator with added EMOTIONAL STORY and occasionally hitting things, but if it's going to look like this all the way through it, I'm in. Astonishing texture work and environment design. I'd be hard pressed to name many other games with objectively better graphics at a purely technical level. And it all runs nicely at 60fps on the PS5.
I then opened up my cupboard and realised I had a massive library of PS4 games on disk (I hadn't even turned the PS4 on for years). I tried Second Son as I'd heard that had a patch for PS5 and was pleasantly surprised. 60fps, looked OK, still played fine. Now just installing Horizon (though I have this on PC and have already played it at 4k with the sliders all hard right) and The Last Of Us (which I might finally finish).
Overall, I am pretty much as I expected to be when I bought it. There's no point me owning a Series X, and the PS5 gives me a quiet, decent way of playing back catalogue PS4 games as well as the odd AAA Sony PS5 single player tentpole release. It's big, looks faintly ridiculous and still has the awkwardness of a console in the first phase of its life, but it also feels like a coherent, fairly well thought out platform that could do well over the next few years. For now, I'm really going to enjoy chilling out on a sofa playing through Rift and GoW.